Tricky to use
Ineffective in removing make-up
I was interested to try this as I am a huge fan of the Benefit They're Real mascara. It is notoriously difficult to remove (although I don't find it too bad with a oil-based cleanser). This was created to solve the problem.
It is a thick cream, which comes in a tube. I wasn't sure how to use it as I had a mini size with no instructions. I tried using a cotton pad and also removing with a flannel and warm water. Ultimately, I didn't like smearing this into my eyes. I also found it didn't remove They're Real mascara or any other mascara any better than my regular cleansers.
+ efficiently cleans Benefit They're Real mascaras and Benefit They're Real eyeliner
+ stylish packaging
+ creamy and mild texture (not a runny one)
+ its mini version is a good travelling companion
- not as efficient with waterproof mascaras of other brands
I got to know a mini version of Benefit They're Real! Mascara and Eyeliner Remover as a part of Sexy on the Run kit due to a wonderful Beauty on Trial giveaway. The remover is basically an odourless white cream contained in a concise tube. It is not runny, and that fact has impressed me in a good way since the tube allows using the exact amount that is needed. The remover deals quite well with mascaras and eyeliner of the Benefit TM, efficiently clearing all traces of make-up. However, it is not so efficient with waterproof mascaras of other brands (and some liners as well), hence you may just end up with 'panda eyes' and will be in need of additional treatment such as micellar water for example. It is also not a very cheap thing to buy on a whim. Thus if you use only benefit eye make-up tools, Benefit They're Real! Mascara and Eyeliner Remover will seamlessly fit into the picture, if not, perhaps you should consider other complimentary removers/cleansers as well.